back to main page

Tuning

The principle of tuning is rather simple, but since there are so much variables it will always stay an art, rather then science.
Science, like the theory presented here, might help you develop the art more, see it as an school for arts.
Most sailors only know "In heavy wind have all as flat as possible, In light winds have a deep curvature.
I will not explain what line to pull to flatten the luff, That is dependant on what boat you are sailing, and might change some other things to.
For example: if you loosen the vang to get more twist, the mast will straighten also if it is flexible.

Sail tuning

For an optimal sail tuning you need to deflect as much air as possible aft.
How to deflect as much as air aft.
Take as much curvature as possible and make your leech directed aft, so parallel with the centerline.
But watch out for:
  • flow separation (=stall). Stall can be detected by the tell tales on the trailing edge going to leeward. This can be caused by:
    • Your sail is too tight
    • Somewhere the curvature is too much for the air to follow.
  • The luff may not backwind.
    If this happens it can be caused by:
    • The sail is too much eased, the wind is than simply blowing in the wrong side of the luff.
    • The angle of attack is too much for the luff.
  • The telltales should point aft over the full height of the sail.
    If this is not happening this can be caused by:
    • If only the upper telltales are going to leeward: Not enough twist.
    • If only the lower telltales are going to leeward: Too much twist.
  • That you still sail the boat, and not the other way around, and your heel is acceptable.
    I you are over powered you are deflecting too much wind, so you have to
    • Ease the sail a little, than you are deflecting the wind less, (and your luff might backwind, so you need less curvature)
    • Give more twist, then the upper part of the sail has less force, (And the upper part also delivers the most heeling moment because it higher.
    • to reduce sail, resulting in simply less force, and the upper part of the sail that gives the most heeling moment is away.
For more about telltales I reccomend to go to: telltales (WB sails) (although I do not fully agree with their last graph.)
Below an illustrated glossary of some of the words to describe the sail profile.
I would like it a lot if someone can correct them to the right words for it.


Twist


The higher you go the more wind there is.
Because of the difference in this apparent and true windspeed the wind will come more from the true wind direction than below.
That is an explanation why you need a little twist.
Other explanation is "taper induced twist" like explained at the bottom of how a sail works
.
When heeling twist also influences the flow in an other way. For high twist and high heeling the wind will be deflected less, and the sail seems more flat from the wind point of view.
In the picture below the blue line indicates the flow path.


Now the same, but now with some twist:

I hope this clarifies the influence of twist when heeled.

When is the twist right:
If all telltales on the trailing edge are directed aft.
If you do not have telltales (which you should) a good indication could be that the luff starts backwinding from top to bottom if you let go the sail just a little.

Picture of http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/lestergilbert/

Telltales



As you might have noticed by now it is important to know how the wind is flowing along your sail.
Because you can not see air you need some sensors. Most simple sensors are some light ropes or tapes hanging free and connected to the trailing edge.
They give you the information if the flow is attached or separated.
In case the flow separates they are blowing to leeward instead of aft.
You can make this telltales yourself, ask your sailmaker, or buy them at a good sailing sports shop.
I have made them myself from some light fabrics, and at rental boats I often use tape from some broken tapes for a tape recorder.

Because the leech is not in your normal point of view it is common practice to also have some gentry tales in your luff (1/3 aft from the mast, at three heights.)
Often there is where the flow separates so they are giving good information.
Please note that sometimes these gentry tales are dancing, while the telltales are nicely streaming.
This dancing of the gentrytales can than be neglected. Probably they are dancing because they are in the turbulent boundary layer.
Often it helps placing them a little more aft, (maybe because there is less turbulence from the mast there, so the flow has re-attached itself again)

I tune by the telltales, the gentry tales more forward are only a help because they are much easier to see.
For more details about telltales I reccomend to go to: telltales (WB sails) (although I do not fully agree with their last graph.)

Sailtuning sailing close hauled.

Speed Vs closer to the wind.

When sailing close hauled you want to go as fast as possible up the wind.
You will have the tendency to have the sail too tight, so with the leech directed somewhat to windward.
This has no use.
Flatten your sail is the solution if you want to go closer to the wind.
Of course you will loose speed with a flattened sail.

Often it is not possible to flatten the sail. giving some more twist and more heeling might help in that case.
Please note on above picture the deflection of the air before it has reached the sail.
This is often called "upwash", the name makes sense if you look at a wing:


Often it helps to make the point of maximal curvature a little more forward.
It helps flattening the leech.

Sailtuning sailing abeam

When sailing abeam, sailing closer to the wind is of no importance. So, you need as much curvature as you an get, or you can handle.

Sail tuning sailing in waves.

waves will make the ship move.
This will make the sail move through the air, constantly changing angle of attack, speed etc.
This makes it necessary to use a tuning that preforms well over a wider region.
Often it helps to go for more speed.

The keel is also moving through the water.
The drift angle varies constantly, and so does the drift resistance. To have a as low as possible drift resistance you need some extra speed to reduce the drift angle.

Balancing the sail force and the keel force.

When you have the sail tuned optimal it might happe that the ship is extremely coming up or bearing away.
You will need a lot of rudder to stay on course, and excessive rudder is slowing the ship down .
This would be a waste of the sail tuning.
A little tendency to come up is good.
This can be explained by the same effect the main and the jib have on eachother.
The jib (here keel) deflected the water already a little for the main (here rudder), so the main needs to be a little more tighter as the jib.
It is bad to have a ship that has the tendency to bear away. This is comparable with sailing ith the jib set for the other tag.

The "argument" is how much the tiller should be too leeward.
This is hard to say, but something like half the drift angle should be about right.

Please note above picture is exaggerated.
The right balance can be obtained with moving the sailforce by moving or raking the mast, or with the heel.

Tuning with the heel.

Beside the influence of heel on the twisted sails, the heel can be of great importance to the ships resistance.
Many ships perform best with a small heel.

Tuning with the heel in length direction.

If the boat is hanging to the aft the stern tends to submerge too much.
Too much is when the flat vertical part is coming so much down, that it gives a turbulent wake.

If the boat is hanging too much forward the stern may be above water, reducing the length of the ship what will result in a lower "hull speed" so more wavemaking resistance.

With what lines to tune your sail.

This is depending on what boat you have and what your sailmaker had in mind.
My recommendation is to go out for a sail in light winds and just pull and loosen every line you can find so you know what line does what.
One remark: If you fully tighten the vang when sailing close hauled with a tight main, your mast might break or bend if you loosenthe sheet only.
Use the traveller to set twist when sailing close hauled, and not the vang.

Enjoy the art of tuning!

Back to main page